A “Good” Spring Training, and The Opening Day Roster
Since reporting to Bradenton in February, the Pirates had a good record, finishing at 18-15 with a few ties thrown in. This isn’t worth much, but it was their first winning spring in six years, and since the only way to maintain any sanity when rooting and writing about this team is to be optimistic, I’m willing to pretend that means something. Aside from wins and losses, more good than bad came out of Florida this Spring. Before any games had started, management locked up the best young players for the next several years in Maholm, Doumit, and McLouth, and all were had at below market average (granted none of them were going to market until at least next year). Once they were actually playing baseball, there were a few big highlights to come out of camp. In no particular order, let’s take a look at the best from Bradenton:
Paul Maholm: Showing no signs of a let down from last year’s big season (relative to the Pirate staff) and contract extension, Maholm made six starts this Spring. In those starts he compiled 26.2 innings and registered a 1.52 ERA, a .68 WHIP, and 14 strikeouts to just one walk. Maholm will get the Opening Day nod in St. Louis against Adam Wainwright, who is certainly beatable. I wouldn’t be surprised to see Pittsburgh take this one, though Maholm will probably have to go at least 7 innings to get the win.

Pedro Alvarez: The number two pick in last year’s draft and the future of the team had great numbers in his first chance at Major League pitching. The
highly anticipated arrival of Alvarez was not a disappointing one. While he didn’t see a ton of playing time, in 20 plate appearances he got on base 10 times with 4 extra base hits including a home run and 5 RBIs. After concerns over his health (fat), he has improved his conditioning and is earning the highest praise from teammates, scouts, and management. He has already hit one homer in practice that witnesses talk about like a thing of legend; over 550 feet, out of the park, and across a lake . He will likely start his career in high A, but I would love to see him get a chance in September when the team is 20 games under .500, or at the very least some quality time in Indianapolis
Ross Ohlendorf had a great spring with a .255 ERA and just under 1.00 WHIP, and
Zach Duke’s numbers would have been the best among Pirates starters except for getting roughed up by the Yankees in one of his seven starts.
Honorable mentions:
Craig Monroe hit eight homers with a .300ish average and .700ish slugging percentage to make the team following a low risk, high reward signing just before camp. He could be a valuable piece at corner outfield if anything goes wrong or if he continues on his tear, and at the very least he should get a couple starts each week against left handed pitching.
Jose Tabata and more surprisingly
Brian Bixleralso stood out with very good numbers. Tabata is blocked by a long line of young outfielders and will start in Double A Altoona, while Bixler should start in Indianapolis and I like him as a sleeper to contribute in the majors should injuries or futility strike the middle infield; gotta like those odds. (How weird is that Tabata story…his wife is a
kidnapping 43-year-old!?)
The Line Up:
Nyjer Morgan. As one of the fastest guys in the Majors and a fan favorite, Morgan is slated to lead off to start the season. I’m a little hesitant about this due to questions of his ability to get on base. Last year he managed a serviceable OBP of .345, but he struggled a bit this spring batting .240 and getting on base at a rate of just .283. He will have to improve these numbers to keep his spot at the top, though I anticipate he will get many opportunities to do so. I see Morgan as maybe the most pivotal part of this line-up. If he can get on base at a .355 mark, steal bases and score runs, he could jump start the offense full of young talent and latent potential and help lead the Pirates out of the NL central basement.
Freddy Sanchez. Sanchez looks to rebound following a sub-par 2008 during which he was plagued by a sore shoulder that affected his hitting. Now healthy and catching the positive vibes that are abound in the clubhouse, Sanchez is once again a threat to bat .320, though he struggled a bit this spring and is now 31 years old.
Nate McLouth. Coming off a great 2008 and a new contract, McLouth will hope to equal his .853 OPS and 26 homer campaign from last year. I’m getting the impression that most critics aren’t expecting him to do so, but I am encouraged by his new spot in the line up that opened up with Morgan’s insertion into the lead off spot. The third spot seems more appropriate for McLouth, and it will hopefully afford him some more RBI chances providing that Sanchez and Morgan can get on base. If he does regress slightly at the plate, the reigning Gold Glove center fielder is guaranteed to play some great defense.
Ryan Doumit. Another one of the few bright spots from 2008, Doumit will look to build on last year’s .858 OPS during which he showed decent power with 16 homers and .357 slugging percentage. The key for him will be staying healthy, and hopefully he can appear in at least 130 games this season (just 116 in ‘08) and get over the 20-25 home run mark to provide some much needed power to the middle of the order.
Adam LaRoche. LaRoche had a solid year in ‘08. For the Pirates it is most important that he gets off to a good start. He is a notoriously slow starter (.164 average in April in the past three years) and struggled a bit this Spring with just a .239 average and 3 home runs.
Brandon Moss. Moss needs to step up soon to meet some of the potential and expectations that have been placed on him since coming over in the Bay deal last summer. In his first chance to play every day, Moss was mediocre with a .246 average and underwhelming on-base and slugging percentages last year. Fears of his injury woes in the off-season were quelled as he showed up healthy and in great shape to camp, but still managed a meager .226 average and just one home run this Spring. I’m not on the bandwagon that many seem to be aboard, and I optimistically hope for a .280 average and 15 home runs in 2009.
Andy LaRoche. Guaranteed a starting job for ‘09 at the end of last season despite a terrible performance at the plate (.163 average and .256 slugging percentage) and in the field last year, the younger LaRoche had a very impressive Spring in both facets batting .333 and slugging .471 and registering only a few errors in the pre-season. I like Andy to have a break out year and finally legitimize the hype that has surrounded him since the Dodgers brought him up last year.
Jack Wilson. Coming off of a
bad 2008, Wilson struggled again this spring with a sub-.200 average while trying to adjust his swing. He will be solid at short but I don’t expect much at the plate, and am secretly hoping to see him platooned rather than start every day.
The bench is much better this year owing to the signing off Craig Monroe,
Eric Hinske, and
Ramon Vazquez. I look for Monroe and Hinske to pick up a lot of at bats as corner outfielders and pinch hit sports. Vazquez could be a solid stop-gap should Wilson, Andy LaRoche, or Freddy Sanchez suffer injuries or are unable to get the job done. Catcher
Jason Jaramillo had an OK pre-season and is a decent back up, though I am confused as to why
Robinzon Diaz lost out on this spot after grossly outperforming Jaramillo at the plate this Spring, batting .423 with an OBP of .464, compared to the former’s .227 and .330. Coming up will be my personal favorite
Andrew McCutchen who showed speed and an ability to get on base throughout the pre-season. Batting .318 with a .423 OBP (12 walks) and a .561 slugging percentage, McCutchen probably earned a roster spot but was kept down for what is reported to be largely a
business matter. I still like McCutchen to get to the Majors by May and hope to see him as part of the crowded outfield rotation. As mentioned before Brian Bixler also had a surprising pre-season batting .345, but will have to exhibit a little more patience as he struck out 14 times to just 5 walks.
The Pitching
By far the biggest liability and what will hinder the Pirates from breaking their 16-year sub .500 slump. The rotation is bursting with young potential while the bullpen has very little depth and will probably look drastically different by the year’s end.
Paul Maholm. We spoke of Maholm’s ‘08 and great pre-season, and there is no room for any decline in his performance if Pittsburgh hopes to get out of the basement. Let’s expect 13 wins and a sub-3.50 ERA to anchor the young staff…and hope for better
Ian Snell. Snell had a disappointing ‘08 to follow up a very promising ‘07, when he hit the 200 innings mark, allowed 3.76 per nine, and a decent 1.33 WHIP. In 2008 his K/BB ratio skyrocketed (1.51 compared to 2.60 the year before) along with his ERA (5.42) and WHIP (1.76). His pre-season numbers weren’t much better with a 5.11 ERA and 1.95 WHIP, but was limited to only three starts and 12.1 innings. The closest thing to a fireballer that the Bucs have, the highlight for Snell was a solid performance in the WBC for Puerto Rico in a couple of appearances offering some hope moving forward.
Zach Duke. Duke had a very nice Spring to improve over a mediocre-to-bad 2008. Over seven starts he had a nice 3.88 ERA and 1.21 WHIP, but was actually much better than these numbers owing to one start when he was blown-up by the Yankees, after which he rebounded nicely shutting out the Twins over 5 innings in his next start.
Ross Ohlendorf. Another pleasant surprise in the pre-season, he may offer the highest upside behind Maholm. He performed well in very limited work out of the Yankee bullpen last year before coming over in the Nady deal. As a starter for Pittsburgh he struggled in just 62 innings with a mid-6.00 ERA and a 1.87 WHIP. However, the 26-year-old had a fantastic Spring with a 2.55 ERA, sub-1.00 WHIP and a 6.5 K/BB ratio. Ohlendorf was among four or five guys competing for the back-end rotation jobs this spring, and certainly earned his spot.
Jeff Karstens. The lesser of three evils as the fifth starter. He “beat out”
Virgil Vasquez and
Tom Gorzelanny (we’ll pretend I wasn’t saying he was going to bounce back all off-season) with a 6.17 ERA and a .326 batting average allowed (!!!!). Perhaps a short-term situation, Karstens will need get his act together to keep his job. Last year he was significantly better in 9 starts for the Pirates, and if he can match that 4.03 ERA and 1.34 WHIP he would be an acceptable fifth starter.
The bullpen will once again be anchored by closer
Matt Cappswho recorded 21 saves and a 3.03 ERA in 49 appearances last year. He was roughed up a bit in 13 appearances in Bradenton to the tune of a 5.84 ERA, but we can expect that to slide closer to and hopefully below 3.00 during the season. At 25, he will be arbitration eligible for the 2010 season. After Capps the next best thing is
John Grabow, who had a very nice ‘08 in 74 appearances with a 2.84 ERA and a solid 1.28 WHIP. He was limited in Bradenton because of his spot with team USA in the WBC, but performed pretty much on par with last year’s stats. The next closest to a “sure thing” in the bullpen is
Tyler Yates who appeared in 72 games last year. I would certainly like to see his control improve following his 1.54 WHIP in ‘08, and he was great this Spring in 13 appearances, striking out better than a batter an inning, allowing only two walks, and recording a 1.93 ERA.
After Yates there are only question marks.
Sean Burnett will likely see a lot of action despite a mediocre ‘08 and poor Spring, and
Craig Hansen has still yet to show the ability to find the strike zone or get people out in his brief career; a sub-6.00 ERA would be a career best. After these two are
Jesse Chavez and
Donnie Veal. Veal is a lefty who was picked up in the rule 5 draft with some reported potential but little experience. Chavez was pretty good as a closer in Indianapolis last year, and is likely to get some chances at middle relief with low expectations. Behind these winners is a big unknown in
Evan Meek. Meek was very good this spring in 10.1 innings despite some control problems, but was riddled with injuries and sickness over the course of the past month. Management didn’t feel comfortable with him on the roster for opening day, but if he can replicate his 3.48 ERA and subdue those walks and hits a bit, he could be a nice option out of the pen by mid-season. There is little coming up in the system, though
Daniel McCutchen’s name is thrown around as a legitimate top prospect and a guy who could make the majors by year’s end. However he struggled mightily in a handful of appearances with the club in Bradenton and is still very young and untested. Look for a revolving door behind Burnett and Hansen, with call-ups and free agent signings likely abound in 2009 for middle relief.
So…
Once the team was assembled in camp, everyone said all the right things ranging from last year’s underachievers (
here and
here), to
up-and-comers, to the few who performed well last year and cashed in. Ryan Doumit has had good things to say about his pitchers, and Freddy Sanchez seemed to have summed up the feel in camp when he said “I think things are going to be different this season…” that’s great news everyone! I’m sure this is a huge departure from years past when the attitudes were “I think we’ll suck again,” and “do you think we can lose a hundred?” Look, I love the positive attitude, new management, new pitching coach, and a new core wrapped up for the next few years; but the pitching shapes up only a little better than last year’s MLB worst 5.08 ERA. To be positive, last year the Pirates started 26 different pitchers over the course of the season. Barring injuries we can hope to see that number reduced by a half, another stellar year from Maholm, and rebounds for Snell and Duke. Duke and Ohlendorf are showing promise and everyone is still young, leading me to believe that this years rotation will be vastly superior to 2008.
I do like this team to improve, but not enough to end the sub-.500 slump which - if all goes perfectly - could happen next year, and certainly the year after if this group stays together. While I expect them to exceed the misery of the previous worst-stretch-ever of the 20s and 30s Phillies and continue the 16 year slump, I also anticipate the beginning of a turnaround. They will better the past four years’ teams and get over that 70 win mark they haven’t hit in five years. 72 wins, and a far more exciting team with genuine talent to enjoy watching develop.